Sun Sulin’s case was profiled by Sixth Tone in 2017 after severe breathing distress developed following nasal surgery in Shanghai. Her story illustrates the central ENS paradox: a nose can look anatomically open while breathing feels profoundly abnormal.
This page is an editorial rewrite of the 2017 Sixth Tone feature preserved on the original website. Statements about Sun’s operation, later findings and medical encounters reflect that report. Historical prevalence estimates quoted in the feature are identified as estimates rather than current established incidence figures.
Before surgery
Before the events described in the report, Sun worked as a project manager at a chemical engineering institute in Shanghai. In 2013 she sought treatment for an itchy, blocked nose and an itchy ear. She was diagnosed with allergic rhinitis and inflammation of the ear canal and later underwent a nasal procedure at a hospital in Shanghai.
Sun remembered the operation as something that had been presented as straightforward. During the procedure she felt an instrument inside the nose but did not believe at the time that anything unusual had happened. The major change came afterward.
Severe symptoms after the 2013 procedure
According to Sixth Tone, Sun soon developed pain with breathing and a persistent sensation of suffocation. The distress was difficult for others to understand because her nasal passages did not appear conventionally obstructed. That mismatch between visible openness and the subjective experience of inadequate breathing became the defining problem in her case.
Her husband, Tao Jie, described a crisis three months after surgery when Sun was convinced she could not breathe. During later periods the combined physical and psychological burden became so severe that family members stayed close to protect her during episodes of self-harm risk.
The original feature contains graphic language used by Sun to communicate the intensity of her air hunger. This redesigned version does not repeat those method details. The medically relevant point is the persistence and severity of the breathing sensation and the degree to which it disrupted sleep, concentration, emotional stability and ordinary daily activity.
Searching for an explanation
Sun said that when she first reported the postoperative symptoms, the open appearance of the nasal passage made some clinicians question how she could feel obstructed or suffocated. At another hospital, she was reportedly told that a substantial portion of an inferior turbinate had been removed. Several doctors later described her condition as suspected Empty Nose Syndrome.
Sun and Tao searched internationally for information and consulted physicians in China and the United States. The Sixth Tone article also discussed the emerging use of a six-item ENS questionnaire. Instruments such as the ENS6Q became important because they attempt to characterize a recognizable symptom pattern rather than defining the condition only by the size of the nasal airway.
The airway may look open while the patient experiences inadequate or unsatisfying nasal breathing.
The report described pain, dryness and abnormal airflow sensation after surgery.
Poor sleep, exhaustion and loss of work capacity became major parts of Sun’s daily life.
The feature quoted a Chinese ENT specialist giving a high estimate for ENS after turbinate reduction in China. That number was a journalistic expert estimate from 2017, not a universally accepted incidence figure, and it should not be used as if it represented modern population-level prevalence.
Sleep, work and daily function
By the time of the 2017 report, Sun was described as spending much of the day in bed and being too exhausted to work. At night she used strategies including humidification and cotton placed in the nose in an attempt to make breathing more tolerable and improve sleep.
The family’s home reflected years of searching for help: medication, medical papers and luggage from repeated treatment trips had become part of everyday life. The financial burden was also substantial. The article reported that the family sold their home in 2015 to help cover medical and treatment expenses.
Sun’s social world had narrowed dramatically. She described most of her contact as being with other people affected by ENS, physicians and researchers. That loss of ordinary work, social life and independence is a major part of the story and helps explain why the condition was experienced as much more than a local nasal complaint.
The problem of recognition
The report repeatedly returns to disbelief. Because routine examinations did not show the kind of blockage expected in conventional nasal obstruction, Sun felt that the severity of her symptoms was dismissed. Even members of her family initially struggled to reconcile what she was saying with what doctors told them.
Tao said that his understanding changed after he researched ENS himself. He became one of Sun’s strongest supporters and joined her in trying to obtain medical recognition. The article also described the wider climate surrounding ENS advocacy in China, including online groups where people expressed extreme anger and despair. Those accounts illustrate distress within some communities but should not be generalized to all ENS patients.
Legal and financial consequences
The Sixth Tone feature also followed Sun beyond the clinic. She pursued legal action against the hospital that performed the surgery, while the report described how the uncertain recognition of ENS in China complicated the question of medical responsibility and compensation. A medical lawyer interviewed for the article explained that the available legal remedies were limited.
For Sun and Tao the financial impact was not abstract. Treatment travel, consultations and attempts to find relief accumulated over several years. The report states that the family sold their house in 2015 to help meet medical expenses. Loss of work capacity then compounded those costs, making the condition a social and economic problem as well as a medical one.
Online ENS communities
Sun also joined internet groups where patients exchanged experiences that were difficult to discuss elsewhere. Those groups gave her contact with people who described similar postoperative breathing sensations, but the article also portrays a community in which some participants expressed extreme despair and anger.
That material is retained in this rewritten article only at a high level. Individual online statements do not describe the ENS population as a whole, and violent or self-destructive reactions should not be treated as defining features of the condition. Their relevance is that the report documented what can happen when severe symptoms, isolation and lack of recognition converge for some individuals.
Family support and advocacy
Sun and Tao began attending awareness activities and speaking publicly because they did not want other patients to reach the same level of suffering without understanding what might be happening. Their focus was recognition of postoperative symptoms, informed discussion before turbinate surgery and access to clinicians familiar with ENS.
The Sixth Tone profile ends quietly rather than clinically: an apartment kept humidified even in winter, stacks of medical material, repeated travel for treatment, and a painting of an open window on the wall. The image captured both the scale of the disruption and the couple’s continuing hope that Sun could find a more manageable way to live with her symptoms.
Why this case remains useful
Sun’s story is unusually well documented for a patient narrative because the original feature combined interviews with the patient and her husband with comments from physicians and a legal specialist. It therefore provides social and historical context that is different from a clinical trial but more structured than an anonymous online post.
The case also illustrates why ENS research moved toward symptom instruments and functional testing. An airway that looks open on examination does not necessarily explain how airflow is perceived. Sun’s experience cannot establish a mechanism by itself, but it gives a concrete example of the clinical problem researchers have since tried to measure more systematically.
Video and original report
Read the original Sixth Tone feature, “The Invisible Pain of Empty Nose Syndrome”.
Inga kommentarer:
Skicka en kommentar